This rich and diverse collection of literary essays related to post-Romantic Arctic Discourses and counter-discourses was generated by an international collaborative network built
up around the multi-faceted “Arctic Discourses” project at the University of Tromsø (2006-2009). Edited by the three project leaders—Anka
Ryall (English), Johan Schimanski (Comparative Literature) and Henning Howlid Wærp
(Scandinavian Literature)—this volume demonstrates the multiplicity of representations
and images of the Arctic found in and formed by texts written from around 1840 to
the present from a variety of cultures, time periods and genres. In addition, numerous
theoretical frameworks are used to examine these images. This diversity, as the editors
point out, makes Arctic Discourses fairly unique, as most previous studies have focused on individual cultures or nations
and have privileged Anglo-American literatures, discourses and perspectives. The multifarious
nature of this collection is also evident when reading over the list of contributors
who range from well-established scholars such as Sherrill Grace to those newer to
academia. While nearly half of the contributors are connected to the University of
Tromsø, the others work at universities in Canada, Britain, Germany, Sweden and Denmark.
Arctic Discourses contains fifteen chapters which are thoughtfully ordered into two parts—“Discovering
the Arctic” and “Imagining and Reimagining the Arctic”—preceded by the editors’ introduction.
This clearly written introduction provides
valuable context by discussing the term Arctic Discourses—defined here as “accounts of the Arctic and appeals to Arctic images… within which we form our expectations of the Arctic” (Ryall, Schimanski, and Wærp
x)—the distinctions and relationships between dominant discourses and counter-discourses,
the notion of “answering back from the Arctic” and the ways in which dominant Western
discourses may gradually change. The broad
range of perspectives in the various chapters are outlined, as well as the thread
which connects them, namely “an interest in studying the formation of the images and
representations of the Arctic
that have persisted over time and have received new functions in the interplay of
different discursive contexts” (Ryall, Schimanski, and Wærp, xiii). Brief comments
about several useful theoretical frameworks, and remarks on each
of the fifteen chapters round out the introduction.
The seven chapters in “Discovering the Arctic” focus primarily on Arctic exploration
accounts. In the first chapter, Hanna Eglinger
draws upon a variety of personal exploration narratives from multiple expeditions
in her discussion of paradoxical metaphors and parabolic narratives, and this is followed
by an article by Johan Schimanski and Ulrike Spring which focuses on numerous accounts
surrounding one particular expedition, namely the Austro-Hungarian Arctic Expedition
of 1872-1874. While some of the chapters offer new perspectives on expedition accounts
and explorers who have previously received substantial attention in Western Europe
and North America, others cover accounts and texts which have received less scholarly
attention in the West. Examples of the former are Henning Howlid Wærp’s accessible
analysis of Fridtjof Nansen’s First Crossing of Greenland (1890) and chapters on the Danish/Greenlandic explorer and ethnographer Knud Rasmussen
by Kirsten Thisted and Fredrik Chr. Brøgger, while examples of the latter are Tim
Youngs’s study of the 1937 Soviet North-Pole 1 Expedition and Susi Frank’s examination
of Soviet Arctic discourse in the 1930s. Frank uses Russian fictional texts with factographical
claims and American and German works of fiction and popular documentaries to demonstrate
why Soviet discourse in the 1930s should be viewed as a counter-discourse to the European
Arctic discourse of the era. It also provides a transition to the second part of the
book which primarily—but not exclusively—focuses on representations of the Arctic
found in fiction, poetry, and music.
As in the first part of the book, analyses of representations of the Sámi and other
indigenous peoples of the North play a prominent role in a number of the chapters
found in part II—“Imagining and Reimagining the Arctic.” Cathrine Theodorsen’s look
at images of the Sámi in travelogues and fiction by German
author Theodor Mügge (1802-1861) and Wendy Mercer’s examination of what she calls
“quasi-scientific-travel-adventure” (180) novels in nineteenth century French prose
fiction are two examples covering the oldest
texts in this section. Maria Lindgren Leavenworth’s use of the gothic horror novel
The Terror (2007)—Dan Simmon’s fictionalized account of Franklin’s fatal expedition—to look
at the challenges of sorting out notions of history and time and Heidi Hansson’s examination
of Arctic crime discourse using Dana Stabenow’s Alaska-based Kate Shugak series employ
newer texts. Lisa Williams’s chapter on “Telling an Arctic Tale: Arctic Discourses
in Canadian Foreign Policy” also focuses on more recent material and underscores the
urgent need to be more inclusive
of indigenous perspectives and voices in Canadian foreign policy.
The final three chapters of Arctic Discourses look at representations of the Artic in Inuit and Sámi poetry and Canadian music.
Laurel Parsons combines these themes in “Anerca: Representations of Inuit Poetry in Twentieth-Century Art Music” and Sherill Grace
discusses how older and newer discourses of the North “collide” in Frobisher (2007)—the only Canadian opera with the Arctic as a theme. In the final chapter of
the book, Harald Gaski explores the work of Sámi poet and multimedia artist Nils-Aslak
Valkeapää who directly conveys an Arctic indigenous discourse. This final chapter
provides a fitting springboard for further dialogue and discussions regarding power
relationships past and present in the Arctic.
One dimension which may appear to be underrepresented in this volume is gender and
Arctic Discourses, but it should be noted that gender roles and the notion of northern femininity does
figure into Hanson’s chapter on crime fiction, and a number of other contributors
draw gendered perspectives into their essays. Additional chapters or material related
to gender and Arctic Discourses might have enhanced this collection, and this area provides, at any rate, fertile
ground for research and publication opportunities for others.
In summary, Arctic Discourses is an invaluable contribution to the growing field of Arctic literary studies, and
it will be of interest to a broad academic audience. While the editors and this review
point out the benefits of reading the essays as a type of dialogue, chapters can be
read and used as stand-alone texts by individuals and as part of undergraduate and
graduate courses. Readers will find ample material and ideas with which to engage,
and these essays will encourage further study and the emergence and awareness of additional
perspectives and discourses on the Arctic.