Over the past few decades, the interdisciplinary field of human-animal studies,
also known as animal studies, has become increasingly popular, evidenced by
the growing number of journals and anthologies dedicated to this topic. With
Dyr og mennesker i norsk litteratur [Animals and People in Norwegian Literature],
Henning Howlid Wærp provides a valuable contribution to the field, using a
variety of literary lenses and frameworks to examine the relationships between
humans and animals in selected Norwegian fictional and non-fictional prose
narratives, from the end of the nineteenth century up until today. While most
chapters focus on novels, Wærp also devotes individual chapters to short
stories, essays, and an exploration narrative. Wild animals, including mammals,
insects, and birds, receive considerable attention, as do pets, and farm animals
also appear. In his prologue, Wærp points out how he had to set boundaries,
both in terms of genre and the types of human-animal relationships
highlighted.
In chapter one, which serves as an introduction, Wærp provides what he
calls “generelle teoretiske refleksjoner” [general theoretical reflections] (9) on
topics such as animals rights, the presence of animals in creative works, the
nuanced and complicated relationships between human and non-human
animals, and conservation. In doing so, he touches on creative works by Nordic
authors ranging from Camilla Collett, Henrik Ibsen, and Sigrid Undset to Tove
Jansson and Kerstin Ekman. He also references a variety of historians, literary
critics, ecocritics, and philosophers, including Martha Nussbaum and her
recently published Justice for Animals: Our Collective Responsibility (2023). Wærp
continues to draw upon the work of these and other thinkers and critics in the
thirteen chapters that follow, including Margaret Atwood, Erin James, Donna
Haraway, and Arne Næss, framing his literary analyses in broad, yet nuanced,
contexts.
As Wærp points out in the prologue, the book’s fourteen chapters can be
read independently of each other and in any order. Reprints of animal-themed
paintings, drawings, and other art works by mostly Nordic artists head each
chapter, all containing an introduction where Wærp lays out his approach, a
conclusion where we are left with questions to consider, and a bibliography.
While Wærp does not use one theoretical framework or approach in this wide-
ranging study (9), he does return to several themes throughout. These include
the contemporary relevance of older literary works, the value of revisiting texts
through new lenses, and økosorg—eco-grief—which all function as refrains in
the book.
Wærp draws on his long career as a literary critic and educator in this
study, and the works of Knut Hamsun and polar literature, two of the research
areas for which he is known, are given prominent positions. Several of the
book’s chapters build on previously published articles, such as chapter 10,
which examines polar bears in Nordic children’s and youth literature, and the
book’s final chapter, 14, on Sámi author’s Sigbjørn Skåden’s 2019 novel Fugl
[Bird], a work of science fiction. These two examples also reveal that some
chapters focus on one author and/or work, while others look at a particular
theme through works by multiple authors. This distinction is also seen when
comparing chapter 2—“Ikke bare en hund—Fire noveller” [Not Merely a Dog—
Four Short Stories], which examines short stories by Per Sivle, Jacob Breda Bull,
Ingvar Ambjørnsen, and Merethe Lindstrøm, written between 1887 and 1994—
and chapters 3, 7, and 8, which focus on human-animal relationships in novels
by Knut Hamsun, Mikkjel Fønhus, and Trygve Gulbranssen respectively.
Two things Waerp does effectively are to highlight works previously
overlooked by scholars and popular audiences alike, as he does in chapter 9 in
his analysis of Tarjei Vesaas’ first four novels (1923–1926), and to revisit
previously studied, sometimes canonical works, through new thematic lenses.
For example, chapter 5 provides a rereading of northern Norwegian Regine
Normann’s debut novel Krabvaag: Skildringer fra et lite fiskevær (1905) [Krabvaag:
Sketches from a Little Fishing Village 2018], focusing on animal life. In chapter 6,
Hamsun’s poetic descriptions of insect life in works such as Pan (1894) are
highlighted, and these are placed in the context of newer works, such as
ecologist Anne Sverdrup-Thygeson’s Insektenes planet (2018) [Buzz, Sting, Bite:
Why We Need Insects 2019] and philosopher Arne Johan Vetlesen’s The Denial of
Nature: Environmental Philosophy in the Era of Global Capitalism (2015).
Chapter 11 examines well-known novelists Cora Sandel, Brit Bildøen, and
Tove Nilsen’s essays on their personal relationships to animals, while chapter
12 features Ole Robert Sunde’s semiautobiographical “sorrow trilogy.” Chapter
13 focuses on Knut Faldbakken’s Uår: Aftenlandet (1974) [Twilight Country 1993],
a work of science fiction which has received increasing attention since 2000.
Wærp’s reading of Faldbakken’s dystopian society, a place in which there is little
animal presence due to people’s destructive actions, is unconventional, and
surprisingly hopeful, looking at the nature and animal life that do remain.
Finally, chapter 4 is noteworthy in terms of its Canadian content. Wærp
revisits Otto Sverdrup’s Nyt Land: Fire Aar i arktiske Egne (1903) [New Land: Four
Years in the Arctic Regions 1904] with new eyes, noting how Sverdrup’s
understanding of the behaviour and characteristics of the animals he and his
men encounter in the Canadian High Arctic gradually changes and develops
during the four-year expedition. Wærp argues that Sverdrup provides a deeper
description of human-animal meetings in the Arctic than other polar expedition
accounts from this era, leading to “en forståelse av den særegne økologien i
Arktis” [an understanding of the distinctive ecology of the Arctic] (83), and
making Sverdrup’s account deserving of new attention.
While introducing his accessible and inviting study, Wærp notes that “å bli
kjent med et dyr er en vedvarende prosess, kanskje ikke så forskjellig fra å bli
kjent med et menneske eller en litterær tekst” [getting to know an animal is an
ongoing process, perhaps not so different from getting to know a person or a
literary text] (8). Dyr og mennesker i norsk litteratur provides readers with
opportunities to become acquainted or reacquainted with a wide variety of
primary and secondary works. In his book, Wærp models the value of returning
to texts we have encountered before, with an open mind and new theoretical
frameworks. Researchers and general readers alike will encounter questions we
face as we share our habitat and lives with animals—questions which encourage
further scholarship and reflection.
While Dyr og mennesker i norsk litteratur is only currently accessible to a
Scandinavian-language audience, one can hope it will be translated in the near
future to make it available to a broader readership.