This edited anthology showcases many of the major contributions from the three-year
international interdisciplinary Arctic Modernities research project, led by Anka Ryall and based at The Arctic University of Norway
(UiT) with major funding support by the Research Council of Norway. The striking image
on the book cover—a woman in bright red Sámi attire standing on a trampoline in a
seemingly desolate field of snow—provides a fitting invitation to explore this series
of fourteen articles, which both challenge traditional and dominant discourses surrounding
the Arctic, and provide valuable new perspectives related to gender and indigeneity.
The articles challenge both long-held and more recently constructed stereotypes and
oversimplified representations of this complex and dynamic region by drawing on historical,
literary, cultural, and aesthetic perspectives.
In their engaging introduction, editors Heidi Hansson and Anka Ryall, both well-known
literary scholars who work extensively with Arctic texts, unpack the cover image to
frame their discussion of the ways in which the Arctic and modernity have been conceptualized
and defined in various times, places, and spaces, focusing on the intersection of
these notions and some of the seeming paradoxes and contradictions that result. Hansson
and Ryall position the articles in this anthology within the following Arctic discourse
framework, which is reflected in the book’s subtitle: “the Arctic understood as threatened
environment, the Arctic perceived as the exotic opposite of modernity and the Arctic described as the everyday, lived reality of its inhabitants” (4, italics mine). The editors also note that
a hypothesis common to many of these contributions is
“the Arctic may be seen as a stark embodiment of the paradoxes of modernity” (8).
The geographic and thematic foci of the articles span the circumpolar north—from Russia
and the former Soviet Union to northern Canada to the northern reaches of the Nordic
region, including Sápmi, Greenland, and Svalbard—with Canadian and Norwegian content
being particularly well represented. The areas of expertise of the contributors, all
of whom are connected to European and North American universities, range from literature
and culture (comparative, Nordic, English, Russian, and Slavic) to art history, Arctic
history, and cross-cultural, gender, film, and media studies. By presenting such a
wide range of perspectives, Hansson and Ryall effectively highlight the broad and
timely range of work related to the Arctic and modernity taking place in the field
of humanities. Arctic Modernities also demonstrates the importance of paying attention to often understudied perspectives
and areas such as “the impact of … air travel, industry, tourism, urgent environmental
concerns and changing
gender norms on discourses of Arctic modernity” (6), when political and economic decisions
are made in areas ranging from the environment
to Indigenous issues.
While a number of the articles use “new” lenses to examine classic texts and authors
that have been heavily studied, others
introduce the readers to less well-known texts and images that have been marginalized
and/or forgotten. Examples of the former are Fredrik Chr. Brøgger’s ecocritical reading
of Helge Ingstad’s iconic The Land of Feast and Famine from 1933 (originally published in Norwegian as Pelsjegerliv blant Nord-Canadas indianere in 1931) and Sigfrid Kjeldaas’ “Icebergs and Light: Modernity and the Arctic Sublime
in Barry Lopez’s Arctic Dreams.” Henning Howlid Wӕrp also discusses Ingstad’s The Land of Feast and Famine, along with texts by polar explorers Fridtjof Nansen and Knud Rasmussen in his thought-provoking
examination of “The Arctic Pastoral.” An example of the latter is Roswitha Skare’s
“The Romance of the Far Fur Country: Indigenous Life between Tradition and Modernity”
in which she analyzes both a classic silent film—Nanook of the North (1922)—and a recently re-discovered film—The Romance of the Far Fur Country (1920).
In addition to the aforementioned articles by Brøgger, Kjeldaas, and Wӕrp, the first
section of Arctic Modernities—“Environmental Arctic”—contains a look at “Ice as a Literary Motif in Soviet Arctic
Modernities” by Susi K. Frank and Renée Hulan’s “The Poetry of the Aeroplane: Arctic
Flight in Twentieth-Century Canadian Poetry.” The second section—“Exotic Arctic”—begins
with a study of “Early Mass Tourism at the North Cape: Infrastructure, Environment
and Social Practices” by Ulrike Spring, followed by Jan Borm’s analysis of “Gender,
Primitivism and the Pictorial in Olive Murray Chapman’s Travelogue Across
Lapland” (1932), and Skare’s film study. Adriana Craciun’s timely look at the complex
political,
cultural, and identity issues surrounding the recent discoveries of the Franklin ships—the
Erebus and the Terror—in northern Canada and Audun J. Mørch’s look at Yuri Rytkheu, a Chukchi writer, rounds
out this section.
The book’s third section, “Everyday Arctic,” contains two articles that focus on Svalbard—a
part of the circumpolar North that
has become more well known outside of the Nordic region in recent years. Anka Ryall
focuses on two personal narratives in her study “Svalbard in and Beyond European Modernity,”
and Elin Haugdal looks at the intersection of identity, gender, and modernity in
the Svalbard images of photographer Herta Grøndal from the 1950s to 1970s. These are
followed by Cathrine Bjerknes’ article in which she uses a lens of “hybridity” to
discuss the representation of the Arctic in Melanie McGrath’s crime fiction novel
White Heat (2011). The final article, “‘A Place in the Sun’: Historical Perspectives on the
Debate on Development and Modernity,” is by Kirsten Thisted, who has worked extensively
with Greenlandic literature and
Danish-Greenlandic relations.
Though Indigenous material and perspectives are included in a number of the analyses,
including Thisted’s study and Audun J. Mørch’s analysis of the Chukchi writer Yuri
Rytkheu, there do not appear to be any direct contributions by Indigenous scholars.
That being said, the range of theoretical, geographical, linguistic, and cultural
perspectives in Arctic Modernities is broad and the articles offer refreshingly nuanced and original perspectives and
readings.
Arctic Modernities: The Environmental, the Exotic and the Everyday will be of interest to students and scholars in literary, cultural, and film studies
and beyond. Instructors will find individual chapters or groups of chapters to be
of use in courses about northern literature, film, and art, as well as tourism, gender,
and cultural studies. The notes and references that accompany the introduction and
each chapter are thorough and serve as a valuable resource for further study. The
book also contains a helpful index, and the way in which the articles are grouped
together is logical and effective.
As with its predecessor “Arctic Discourses” research project, the “Arctic Modernities”
project, as evidenced by this anthology, has demonstrated the richness and originality
that results from interdisciplinary research initiatives, and it has contributed valuable
new perspectives to Arctic Studies by exploring the complex discourses surrounding
the Arctic region and modernity.